Table of Contents Plus Alternative With Scroll Spy and Dark Mode
Table of Contents Plus is a long-running, free and light plugin. Tidy Table of Contents adds scroll spy, three themes with dark mode, ACF fields and exclusion by category or tag, still for free.
Why replace Table of Contents Plus?
Scroll spy and themes
The heading you are reading is highlighted in the TOC, and three themes (Minimal, Card, Highlight) adapt to dark mode. Neither is mentioned on the Table of Contents Plus listing.
Finer exclusions
Skip the TOC on chosen categories or tags, or drop headings by text pattern or CSS class. Table of Contents Plus excludes headings by name with wildcards and hides the TOC with [no_toc].
Your settings come with you
Tidy Table of Contents can read your Table of Contents Plus settings and map them to its own, from its settings page, in the free version.
ACF fields and schema
Headings stored in ACF fields can be included, and SiteNavigationElement schema is added to the page.
A complete free version
Automatic insertion, the TOC block, the [tidy_toc] shortcode, smooth scroll, a collapsible TOC that remembers its state, scroll spy, three themes with dark mode, collapsible sub-headings, exclusion by category, tag, text pattern or CSS class, device targeting, ACF fields, SiteNavigationElement schema, a built-in cache and a settings import from Easy Table of Contents and Table of Contents Plus are all free.
Optional Pro
Pro ($29/year for one site, $89 lifetime) adds a sticky TOC, a floating TOC button, a reading progress bar, copy-anchor links, view more/less, reading time, a custom theme, a sidebar widget, an Elementor widget, extra shortcode attributes and settings export/import. Agency ($79/year) covers unlimited sites.
Tidy Table of Contents vs Table of Contents Plus
| Feature | Tidy TOC | Table of Contents Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Active installs (WordPress.org) | Fewer than 10 | 200,000+ |
| Tested up to | WordPress 7.1 | WordPress 7.1 |
| Automatic insertion | ||
| Smooth scroll | ||
| Block | ||
| Sidebar widget | Pro | |
| Scroll spy | Not mentioned | |
| Dark mode | Not mentioned | |
| Exclude by category or tag | Not mentioned | |
| ACF fields | Not mentioned | |
| Price | Free / Pro $29 per year | Free |
Table of Contents Plus 202609.1: WordPress.org listing, checked on November 18, 2026. "Not mentioned" means the feature does not appear on its listing.
Moving away from Table of Contents Plus
What Table of Contents Plus does well
Table of Contents Plus (200,000+ active installs, version 202609.1 updated on September 17, 2026) inserts a TOC automatically once a post has enough headings, scrolls smoothly, lets you pick heading levels, exclude headings by name with wildcards and hide the TOC with [no_toc]. It also offers a widget, a block and a [toc] shortcode. It is free, with no Pro version.
What Tidy Table of Contents does
Automatic insertion, the TOC block, the [tidy_toc] shortcode, smooth scroll, a collapsible TOC that remembers its state, scroll spy, three themes with dark mode, collapsible sub-headings, exclusion by category, tag, text pattern or CSS class, device targeting, ACF fields, SiteNavigationElement schema, a built-in cache and a settings import from Easy Table of Contents and Table of Contents Plus are all free. Pro ($29/year for one site, $89 lifetime) adds a sticky TOC, a floating TOC button, a reading progress bar, copy-anchor links, view more/less, reading time, a custom theme, a sidebar widget, an Elementor widget, extra shortcode attributes and settings export/import. Agency ($79/year) covers unlimited sites.
Switching
Install Tidy Table of Contents, open its settings and import your Table of Contents Plus settings, then deactivate Table of Contents Plus. The [toc] and [no_toc] shortcodes are not converted: use the TOC block, the [tidy_toc] shortcode or the per-post setting instead.
When Table of Contents Plus is the better choice
- You want a free sidebar widget. Table of Contents Plus includes one; in Tidy Table of Contents the widget is in Pro.
- You rely on its shortcodes. If many posts use [toc] or [no_toc], switching means editing them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Table of Contents Plus still maintained?
Can I import my Table of Contents Plus settings?
Does Tidy Table of Contents highlight the current heading?
What is included in the free version of Tidy Table of Contents?
What does Tidy TOC Pro add?
Compare with other table of contents plugins
Try a Table of Contents Plus alternative
Install Tidy Table of Contents from WordPress.org. It adds a table of contents to your posts with the default settings.
Get it free →