Alternative to SimpleTOC

SimpleTOC Alternative: Same SSR, More Features

Love SimpleTOC's server-side rendering but want smooth scroll, collapsible sections, and auto-insert? Tidy TOC delivers the same zero-CLS performance with more out of the box.

Why choose Tidy TOC over SimpleTOC?

Smooth scroll included

SimpleTOC deliberately omits smooth scrolling to stay minimal. Tidy TOC includes smooth scroll out of the box in the free tier, giving readers a polished navigation experience without any extra configuration.

Collapsible sections

SimpleTOC does not offer collapsible/toggle functionality. Tidy TOC lets readers collapse the table of contents to save space, which is especially useful on mobile devices and long-form content.

Exclude specific headings

Tidy TOC allows you to exclude headings by pattern, so you can hide headings like 'Related Posts' or 'Comments' from the TOC. SimpleTOC has no built-in exclude mechanism.

Auto-insertion support

Tidy TOC can automatically insert the table of contents before the first heading on all posts and pages. SimpleTOC requires you to manually place the block in every post.

Pro upgrade path with sticky sidebar

Tidy TOC Pro offers a sticky sidebar mode where the TOC follows the reader as they scroll. SimpleTOC has no premium tier and no advanced positioning features.

Same SSR approach, more features

Both Tidy TOC and SimpleTOC use server-side rendering for zero CLS. But Tidy TOC adds smooth scroll, collapse, exclude patterns, and auto-insert on top of the same performance foundation.

Tidy TOC vs SimpleTOC — Feature comparison

FeatureTidy TOCSimpleTOC
PriceFree / $49 ProFree only
Gutenberg Block
Server-Side Rendering
Smooth Scroll
Collapsible TOC
Custom Heading Levels
Exclude Headings
Auto-Insert
Sticky/Fixed SidebarPro
Nested/Hierarchical List
Zero CLS
Minimal Footprint
Actively Maintained
WordPress 6.0+

SimpleTOC vs Tidy TOC: an in-depth comparison

Two SSR plugins, different philosophies

SimpleTOC and Tidy Table of Contents are the two main WordPress TOC plugins that use server-side rendering. Both render the table of contents in PHP, resulting in zero Cumulative Layout Shift and immediate indexability by search engines. This puts them in a different category from JavaScript-based TOC plugins like Easy Table of Contents or LuckyWP.

The difference is philosophy. SimpleTOC follows a "do one thing" approach: it extracts headings and generates a nested list. No smooth scroll, no collapse, no auto-insert, no exclude patterns. If you want any of these, you need custom CSS or JavaScript.

Tidy TOC takes the position that smooth scroll, collapsible sections, and auto-insertion are essential features that most TOC users expect. These are included in the free tier without compromising the SSR performance foundation.

The smooth scroll question

SimpleTOC's developer has deliberately excluded smooth scrolling, arguing that it is a browser-level concern (via CSS scroll-behavior: smooth) rather than a plugin responsibility. This is a valid technical position, but it places the burden on the site owner to add smooth scrolling via theme CSS or a custom snippet.

Tidy TOC includes smooth scroll out of the box with a lightweight vanilla JavaScript implementation. It works consistently across browsers and respects the user's reduced-motion preferences. For most site owners, having smooth scroll built in is more convenient than adding it manually.

Auto-insert: a significant workflow difference

With SimpleTOC, you must manually add the block to every post where you want a table of contents. For a blog with hundreds of existing posts, this means editing each one individually.

Tidy TOC's auto-insert feature automatically adds the TOC before the first heading on all posts (or specific post types). This is especially valuable for existing sites with large content libraries, where manually editing every post is impractical.

When minimal is enough

SimpleTOC is an excellent plugin for developers and minimalists who want a clean, unstyled TOC that they can customize with their own CSS. Its small footprint and lack of options make it predictable and easy to integrate into custom themes. If you are building a theme and want full control over TOC styling and behavior, SimpleTOC's minimal approach gives you a clean canvas.

When SimpleTOC is the better choice

SimpleTOC may be preferable in these situations:

  • You want maximum minimalism. If you prefer a plugin that does the absolute minimum and lets you handle everything else with custom code, SimpleTOC's philosophy aligns better with your approach.
  • You are building a custom theme and want full styling control. SimpleTOC outputs clean, unstyled HTML that you can style entirely with your theme's CSS. Tidy TOC includes its own styles (which can be overridden, but SimpleTOC starts from a cleaner slate).
  • You do not need smooth scroll, collapse, or auto-insert. If these features are genuinely unnecessary for your use case, SimpleTOC avoids loading any code for them. The performance difference is negligible, but the code simplicity is real.
  • You handle smooth scrolling at the theme level. If your theme already sets CSS scroll-behavior: smooth globally, you do not need a plugin to duplicate this. SimpleTOC's anchor links will scroll smoothly via the theme's CSS.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does SimpleTOC compare to Tidy Table of Contents?
SimpleTOC and Tidy TOC share the same server-side rendering approach, meaning both produce zero CLS. The difference is in features: SimpleTOC is intentionally minimal, omitting smooth scroll, collapsible sections, exclude patterns, and auto-insertion. Tidy TOC includes all of these in its free tier while maintaining the same SSR performance.
Is SimpleTOC faster than Tidy TOC?
Both plugins use server-side rendering and produce similar page load performance. SimpleTOC loads slightly less CSS since it has fewer features to style, but the difference is negligible (a few hundred bytes). Both plugins produce zero layout shift and require no JavaScript for TOC rendering.
Does SimpleTOC support smooth scrolling?
No. SimpleTOC intentionally omits smooth scrolling as part of its minimal philosophy. Clicking a TOC link jumps directly to the heading without any scroll animation. Tidy Table of Contents includes smooth scrolling in the free tier, using a lightweight vanilla JavaScript implementation.
Can I collapse the TOC with SimpleTOC?
No. SimpleTOC does not include a collapse or toggle feature. The TOC is always fully expanded. Tidy Table of Contents offers collapsible sections in the free tier, allowing readers to minimize the TOC to save screen space.
Does SimpleTOC have auto-insertion?
No. With SimpleTOC, you must manually place the block in every post or page where you want a table of contents. Tidy Table of Contents offers an auto-insert feature that automatically adds the TOC before the first heading, saving time on sites with many posts.
Should I choose SimpleTOC or Tidy TOC?
If you want the absolute minimum TOC with no extra features and are comfortable placing the block manually in every post, SimpleTOC is a solid choice. If you want smooth scroll, collapsible sections, exclude patterns, auto-insertion, and an optional Pro tier with sticky sidebar, Tidy TOC offers all of that with the same SSR performance.

SSR performance with the features you expect

Get the same zero-CLS performance as SimpleTOC, plus smooth scroll, collapsible sections, and auto-insert. Free to start.

Get TOC Free →